SBOE Cannot Figure Out What Is Going On With Math Standards;

Students statewide struggle with higher math standards

By Ericka MellonNovember 20, 2014 Updated: November 20, 2014 8:42pm

Groups reset, cancel as storms approach Students statewide struggle with higher math standards Only 1 HISD magnet program to end after appeals Poor water service forces Aldine charter school to flush toilets HISD okays Arabic immersion schools

In homes across Texas, parents say their children are in tears over math homework.

Some students who used to make A's have seen their grades plummet.

Three months into the academic year, public school classrooms are absorbing the impact of the state's tougher math standards. In many cases, concepts that used to be covered in higher grade levels now must be taught to younger children.

The State Board of Education heard concerns Thursday from parents, teachers and administrators about the new standards, but little immediate relief is expected. The math changes took effect in elementary and middle school this school year; they will roll out in high schools next year.

Many agree the higher expectations are good - some districts report students are rising to the challenge - but the learning curve is steep. And pressure is ramping up as teachers prepare students for the mandatory standardized exams known as the State of Texas Assessments of Academic Readiness this spring.

"Children are making comments like, 'I am stupid. I'm not good at school,' " Andrea Gonzales, an elementary school principal in the Wimberley Independent School District, told a State Board committee meeting Thursday in Austin. "It's causing them to vomit and to have stress."

Texas Education Commissioner Michael Williams has agreed that students will not be held back if they score poorly on the math part of the STAAR this school year, but others are pushing for reduced pressure on teachers and school districts.

The Texas Association of School Administrators wants Williams to remove math performance from school accountability ratings this year.

Annual math tests

....

The State Board approved the new math standards in 2012 as part of its regular review of different subject areas but held off on implementation until this school year to allow for the adoption of new textbooks and to give teachers time to prepare. Texas has revised its math standards over the years but the latest changes are the biggest overhaul since they were created in the late 1990s.

....

Bonnie Scheidt, a math curriculum specialist for Pearland ISD, offered an example: In the past, sixth-graders were taught to multiply decimals. The skill now is supposed to be learned in fifth grade. She said teachers tried to introduce some concepts earlier last year so students wouldn't start this school year with a large gap in skills.

Making adjustments

....

Bridget McKinney, a math specialist from Alief ISD, told the State Board that students who used to make A's are making B's. But she said the higher expectations will help students graduate ready to compete with their peers across the globe.

"It's a multiyear process, but ultimately our kids can do it," said Earl Snyder, another math specialist from Alief. "When I go into our classrooms now, our kids can reason and talk mathematically, and they've never been able to do that before. It's good for kids."

Drew Davis, whose son is a first-grader in Cypress-Fairbanks ISD, said he's frustrated for the 6-year-old.

"He's getting word problems that are subtraction problems, and he hasn't been taught subtraction yet," Davis said. "Everybody's so busy pointing the finger at someone else that the kids are just being lost in the shuffle."

Parents tuned in

Cy-Fair ISD, the state's third-largest district, held three meetings in October that drew Davis and hundreds of other parents seeking clarity on the math standards.

Linda Macias, Cy-Fair's associate superintendent of curriculum, said in an interview that she hopes state officials consider relaxing the school accountability requirements for math this year.

"We've had to come in and fill in some of the gaps," she said. "But once we get past this, I believe it will be OK. The whole purpose is to provide a deeper understanding in math."

The State Board's instruction committee agreed Thursday to ask the full board to create a committee of parents and teachers to offer recommendations on the math standards.

Board member Geraldine "Tincy" Miller, a Republican from Dallas, said she knows the board approved the math standards two years ago but she now wishes for a slower rollout.

She also echoed concerns expressed by some parents that the changes overlap with the politically divisive Common Core education standards adopted by most other states.

"There were tears in my eyes listening to this," Miller said after several hours of public testimony. "I don't want to sit here and turn these parents away and say, 'Sorry, we can't do anything.' "

Ericka Mellon

Reporter, Houston Chronicle

To read the entire article, go here:  http://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/education/article/Students-statewide-struggle-with-higher-math-5907677.php?cmpid=subem

4 Comments

McGarr

"There were tears in my eyes listening to this," Miller said after several hours of public testimony. "I don't want to sit here and turn these parents away and say, 'Sorry, we can't do anything.' "

Oh, but Tincy, there IS something you can do!

How about insisting that Texas' public schools change their curriculum to fit the STAAR test and adhere to the TEKS that the SBOE approved? The STAAR tests are great and fit what the SBOE said they had to do. It's the superintendents who are violating the law by not changing the curriculum as they are supposed to do. Students can't pass the STAAR Test with anything but a 37% level of passing in Katy ISD. That's horrible. Put the standard at 70%. Then see how many "pass."

One of the problems that is not being talked about is the fact that the math curriculum was dumbed down several years ago so that students were not taught things until later years. The use of fractions, the decimal point, doing long division were all moved to later grades--thus students were not taught them at the proper time.

Teaching elementary mathematics isn't rocket science! Well educated teachers have taught elementary math quite well for hundreds of years before the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics stuck their noses into the process and messed it up--all in the name of "reform."

As for the superintendents who will not comply by updating the curriculum to fit the test, fire them; fine them; throw them out on their ear.

That's what you can do!

Mary McGarr

1 day remaining to edit or remove this post.

17 minutes ago (edited recently) 1 Likes

GERALD Rank 6

Public School courses in Reading, wRiting, and aRithmetic courses are very useful and benefit the students later in their lives.

Public School courses in social studies, literature, philosophy, history, women’s studies, black studies, basket weaving, art, cooking, etc. are not necessary or even useful.

Public schools should not spend taxpayer's money to teach these useless classes that will not benefit the students.

Our Lt. Governor elect Dan Patrick has stated that he wants to eliminate Algebra 2 as a requirement for a High School Degree in Texas!

Not requring Algebra 2 would be further "dumbing down" of the value of a Texas high school degree.

This would leave the Texas high school graduates only qualified to become janitors, radio announcers, insurance salesmen or politicians.

My daughter took differential Calculus in High School.« less

23 hours ago (edited) 2 Like

Dave Mundy Rank 365

It's not the "standards" that are the problem, it's the Common Core-based METHODOLOGY being used by Texas schools in full violation of HB462. The standards themselves aren't a problem and are easy to accomplish using traditional Type I instruction. Instead, Texas schools, trained in the implementation of Common Core methodology, are trying to teach Type I standards using Type II (outcomes-based) methodology. Small wonder kids, teachers and parents are tearing their hair out.

But the Chron would never dare question why Texas schools are violating the law, they got the check from Bill Gates just like the administrators did.« less

1 day ago 2 Like

Howard Rank 61616

@Dave Mundy My son has struggled with math so much he can't stand going to school and isn't able to enjoy any of the positive things it offers. The state politicians need to listen

15 hours ago 1 Likes